Regulation

The penalties deadline is 20 October. The official text still says 14 October.

4 min readMati Melchior
The penalties deadline is 20 October. The official text still says 14 October.

Regulation (EU) 2023/1230 applies on 20 January 2027, and Article 50(2) requires every member state to tell the Commission what breaking it will cost. That deadline falls on 20 October 2026, ninety-two days earlier.

I went looking for the 20 October date in the official text. The first copy I opened printed a different one.

The most-linked official page for this Regulation still serves the uncorrected version. It carries the text exactly as first published in the Official Journal of 29 June 2023. There, Article 50(2) gives the notification deadline as 14 October 2026, and the same page dates the Regulation's own application to 14 January 2027. Read on 13 September 2026, both were still there.

A corrigendum published on 4 July 2023 fixed all of them. It makes fourteen date corrections across Articles 6, 47 and 50 to 54: thirteen shift a date forward by six days, and the fourteenth corrects a year, reading 20 October 2026 for 14 October 2023 in Article 54. The operative text is the Official Journal text as corrected by that corrigendum. EUR-Lex's consolidated version renders 20 October 2026 and 20 January 2027, but it opens by disclaiming legal effect and naming the Official Journal as the authentic version. No single official page simply shows the right date. A specialist summary from MAAK Advocaten gives the deadline as October 2026, naming no day at all, which neither confirms the correction nor contradicts it.

What that date attaches to is not administrative. Article 50(1) requires penalties that are "effective, proportionate and dissuasive and may include criminal penalties for serious infringements". The six-day error sits on the deadline for declaring exactly that.

The guide that will explain the new Regulation is expected in the fourth quarter of 2026. IBF Solutions, reporting a Commission reply of 6 August 2026, places it there, and the same source describes an Editorial Group meeting on 9 April 2026, a status report on 27 April 2026, and subgroup drafts originally due in February 2026 that have slipped. The Commission set the date itself: IBF Solutions reports the Expert Group on Machinery of 17 June 2025 stressing a commitment to publish the guide by 20 January 2027. The official minutes sit on CIRCABC and I did not open them, and the August reply behind the fourth-quarter date was not accessible either.

The last time the Commission explained a machinery law, the explanation arrived well after the law. Its Guide to application of the Machinery Directive 2006/42/EC records both dates in its introduction: the new Machinery Directive has been applicable since 29 December 2009, and the 2nd Edition of the Guide was endorsed by the Machinery Committee on 2 June 2010. That is roughly five months of applicable law before that edition arrived. The guide describes itself as drawn up in comparison with a 1st Edition, so an earlier edition preceded it and the June 2010 endorsement is the second. Its date I could not establish, which leaves it unmeasured rather than early or late.

That guide is equally clear about what it is worth. It states that only the Machinery Directive and the texts implementing its provisions into national law are legally binding. A guide is guidance, not law, and a manufacturer complies with the Articles rather than with a PDF. That is the strongest objection to all of this, and it settles a different question: the subject here is interpretive certainty, not legal obligation.

Article 50(2) binds member states, not manufacturers. A missed notification exposes a government to infringement proceedings, not a company to a fine. That is why the German case is worth naming. Germany's Maschinendurchführungsgesetz entered into force on 6 December 2025, roughly ten months ahead of the notification deadline, and its section 9 lists twenty-six numbered administrative offences with fines up to €10,000, and up to €100,000 for three of them. Section 12 defers sections 8 to 11 to 20 January 2027, so the state that legislated early timed its penalties to the Regulation's own date.

Germany is one of twenty-seven, and what the others have notified is the part I could not establish. I searched EUR-Lex, the Commission's own pages and national sources across four formulations, and no public register of Article 50(2) notifications came back. That is an absence in the published record, not evidence that nothing at all has been notified.

Lateness is also measured against an invented baseline: no provision of the Regulation requires a guide at all. But the date by which one was promised was reported from the Commission's own expert group.

If the guide lands in October and a register of notifications exists somewhere I did not look, most of this dissolves. The date does not. On 20 January 2027 the Regulation applies, in whatever state the guidance is in. The copy of it that most people open first still misprints the deadline for saying what non-compliance costs.

Share

Physical AI Safety Dispatch

Monthly analysis. No spam. One exclusive insight per issue.

One issue per month. Unsubscribe in one click from any email. Privacy policy.

Regulation

When a software update makes you a new manufacturer — and when it doesn't.

Article 18 of Regulation (EU) 2023/1230 will make anyone who substantially modifies a machine its manufacturer — new conformity assessment, new risk assessment, new technical documentation, new declaration of conformity, new CE mark. Article 3(16) says the modification can be digital. It then gates that on two mechanical outcomes, and whether a machine-learning model update clears them is not settled by the instrument, its recitals, or the Blue Guide. What is settled is the exit: an update the original risk assessment already foresaw is not a substantial modification at all.

Read →

Regulation

You have 127 days. Nobody publishes how long this takes.

127 days separate 15 September 2026 from 20 January 2027, when Regulation (EU) 2023/1230 will apply. Seven certification bodies were checked for a published duration benchmark and not one publishes it, so what follows is what is documented instead: the first assessor notified on 8 September 2024, roughly twenty-eight months before the Regulation applies, no harmonised standard yet cited under the Regulation, and seven trade associations on record that machinery was the only sector left out of the Omnibus IV transition period.

Read →

We use cookies

This site uses essential cookies to function and, with your consent, analytics cookies (Google Analytics) to understand how the site is used. Learn more.